The Morning Call of Allentown had an interesting piece this weekend on the Wilkes-Barre newspaper showdown. If you missed it,
check it out. It's a good rundown of the 25-year-old fight between the Times Leader and The Citizens' Voice.
There's a lot at stake in this showdown. The TL is fighting to stay alive, as CV parent company Times-Shamrock considers a takeover. And, and both papers still resent each other...you know, newspaper strike and all. What is also at stake here is the quality of journalism.
You can compare a possible TL/CV merger to Nexstar's takeover of WBRE and WYOU. Before the takeover, both stations were independent of, and competed against each other. It wasn't enough to take down ratings giant WNEP, but both stations did their best to fight for second place. From the look of the newscasts to the stories themselves, both took their own approach. And all was good. If you didn't like how WBRE did a story, you could head to WYOU, and vice versa.
And then Nexstar Broadcasting came into the picture.
WBRE and WYOU (which is owned by a Nexstar shell company) were suddenly whisked together in the same building. What is the result?
Pennsylvania Morning,
Pennsylvania Midday, and evening newscasts that really don't offer anything unique. I can look at video of a fire on WBRE, and then switch to WYOU, and see the same footage minutes later. The quality of journalism at the Nexstar duopoly has suffered since the takeover. Why offer something different, when you and your competitor share the same newsroom?
I don't know if anything similar would happen to the TL, should Times-Shamrock move in. But after seeing how Nexstar basically killed the identities of WBRE and WYOU, let's just say I am
very wary about two competing news outlets being owned by the same company.